BANANA REPUBLIC Black Walnut Eau de Toilette Spray for Men, 3.4 Ounce, brown (I0029003)

My husband loved this. The smell is sweet. Great longevity of fragrance.

Great gift

Gotten lots of compliments wearing it. Lasts all day long and only gets better with time.

I have no clue what the old original cologne smells like. However I enjoyed the scent, it smells like older men working in the woods then went to smoke a cigar. My father in law used to wear this cologne often when it was sold in store. However he said they changed the scent and it smells different now, still good but definitely not the original.

I absolutely love Banana Republic! This scent is my go-to all day, everyday!

Had to get it twice and it’s amazing

It’s the real cologne, but doesn’t last long and it’s a light scent. Perfect for when getting out the showers or maybe to wear at night. More like a fall/winter cologne.

This Amazon version of Black Walnut has very nice scent. I still have a little bit left of a bottle of Black Walnut I bought from Banana Republic in 2010 and when I smell them separately, the scents are almost identical (cognac, tobacco, and cedar wood) However, it does smell like either the tobacco or cedar wood component is missing from the Amazon Black Walnut that I can smell in the BR Black Walnut. The bottle is similar to the original minus the name and banner wrapped around the top. The cap is also light in weight compared to the original. I know Banana Republic discontinued Black Walnut (which is a shame) but if you're a fan of the cologne, I recommend this Black Walnut from Amazon.