e.l.f. No Budge Matte Shadow Stick, One-Swipe Cream Eyeshadow Stick, Long-Wear & Crease Resistant, Matte Finish, Bombshell

Very pretty- makes grey eyes look green. Last well too. Good value

I bought this on a Wirecutter, New York Times, recommendation for inexpensive, effective drug store makeup. The color that was recommended is (apparently) the only neutral color option in the line. It's VERY neutral on my light tan skin. But it stays put, is easy to apply, I like it. Can't be beat at $5.

Update.Works well. Stays and definitely does what indicates with no smudge and stays well in the eye crease. The color here looks different than the color I received. This appears yellow looking. Not a light brown color. That could be just me. Still impressed with how well it works. It sets fairly quickly.Giving a 4 because the color looks yellow.

No budge? Yes it does. It's very creamy....but I like the color and ease of application

Amazing eyeliner pencil and an incredible price. Have paid 7x the price at cosmetics counters for liners that are hard and painful. Great product. The coffee color is subtle.

As someone who was recently diagnosed with rosacea (along with ocular rosacea), I bought multiple shades due to me having to toss out all of my beloved eyeshadows. Despite this line not having very many colours, I read all the ingredients and was pleasantly surprised to see this was non-comedogenic (meaning it will not clog your pores). After wearing this for a night out with my friends, even after accidentally sleeping in this eye makeup, I was VERY shocked to see that I did NOT break out around my eyes. Overall, this has been a great purchase and I genuinely hope that e.l.f. cosmetics decides to expand their shade range!12/10 product. <3

Pretty color and wears well. No smudges. But I ended up giving this eyeliner to my granddaughter, my eyes didn't like it.

Went on smoothly and stayed, I like how I didn't have to make too many passes to get the deep shade I wanted. Now it did come with those white specks that some other reviews talked about but I just wiped it off with a tissue, and doing so I did break the makeup part but I just stuck it back in the hole and it's working just fine if I end up having to use a brush to apply it that's ok with me, I like this product. There's been no eye irritation and I have not had to reapply it at all.