NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPVivid Matte Liquid Liner, Smear-Resistant Eyeliner with Precise Tip - Black

I'm so happy that I found this liquid eyeliner, it comes in beautiful colors and it lasts all day. It's waterproof very smudge resistant, and it's not regular eyeliner waterproof, you need to use makeup remover to really get it to come off easily otherwis, it could become a chore to get it all off.The tip is very skinny so it is very easy to use you can put a thin line on or a thick line totally up to you easy to do either way, nice clean application and texture.Awesome brand, awesome quality, awesome value for your money! I highly recommend.

I used to loved this eyeliner and its always sold out. When I tried using it this time the color was a bit sheer, the brush was a little messed up, & the product is clumpy! Its like i took a brush to an eyeliner gel instead of a liquid liner and its super dry!I did a swatch test, the first 4 lines from the left are from this liner. The 4 following are a swatch from elf liquid liner. I didn’t even need to swipe of excess liner from the nyx liner bcs there was barely any! The elf liquid liner was practically dripping in comparison…

Love it! It’s easy to apply, lasts all day, has a rich dark black color, and comes with a precise brush for perfect lines.

I've had using this for a few months now, it's easy to use, not much smudging it goes on smoothly with no bumps texture wise, it actually does fairly well on the water, and goes on a shimmery black. It was worth the money, though the only two problems I have is the glitter or shimmer stays on the skin afterwards and the flakiness after it dries.Other than that, it's a solid eyeliner that I love using for work!

This is absolutely a beautiful, perfect pastel pink color. I was really worried that it wouldn't show up as most pastels don't have enough pigmentation for brown skin, but it's just as the name says, vivid and bright. It shows up great, is easy to apply, and adds an adorable pop of color to otherwise plain makeup. It takes a bit of time to dry and if you aren't careful you can apply too much at once, but if you're experienced with liquid liner already you don't have to worry. It also is not smudge proof and is very easy to wipe off with just a small bit of pressure, but to me that's a plus because I hate having to scrub off makeup at the end of the day. I will definitely be buying this in more colors.

I have used this eyeliner for 8+ years and it was always my go-to. I would buy multiples at a time and each would last MONTHS. Since the reformulation, it seems like they dry out faster and faster. I had it on “subscribe and save” and even moved my subscription to every 2 months since the quality was dropping so quickly after opening. The last 2 I’ve gotten have been so crusty and dry that they went straight in the trash. Picture is from the first time I opened this tube, and it’s already completely unusable. Unsubscribed and never repurchasing again.Essence Liquid Ink waterproof liner is the closest in formula and brush type if you’re looking for a replacement. The formula is flakier than the (original formula) Nyx one but the eyeliner is cheaper, the tubes last longer, and the last one I bought didn’t have to go directly into the trash.

I love this color and it shows up on eyes great and doesn't smear and stays on

Kinda what I expected for the price. This dries out fast - you have to be putting it on the second you take it out or back in the tube. I can barely do one line before it's like paste. The product in the tube is already getting dry and its not like I leave the top off for more than a second. I am not sure this is totally full.The color (white) is really bright! That's not always easy to find.It lasts a long time, but starts to get crumbly.It dries fast on my eyelid - no time for mistakes.The value = the quality, so...