Kaely Ruby Red Longwear Liquid Lip Liner Waterproof, 24 Hour Long Lasting Lip Liner Stain Marker Pen, 2-in-1 Matte Semi Permanent Lipliner & Lipstick, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, 09

I thought it would be ok but not expecting much since you usually get what you pay for. I was pleasantly surprised!! I love this stuff! It sometimes is difficult to get more out to fill in the lips but I gave it five stars because the price makes it worth it. I’m ordering a couple more of different colors and so I don’t ever run out. I got orchid (very fair skin) and it looks pretty natural. It stays on all day, even after eating. I maybe touch up here are there but probably don’t need to. Highly recommend!

Disappointed, beautiful color but poor quality! The colors of this product are absolutely beautiful, and when I first used it, it stayed on for a very long time. I was really happy with how well it matched my skin tone and how my lips looked. Unfortunately, I only got to use it once. By the next day, the pencil had dried out completely, even though I had closed it properly and stored it in a cool area. I had planned to use it for an event, but it was no longer usable. I'm very disappointed. Although I could return it, I don't think its worth replacing. I feel like I wasted my money. Its such a shame because it had great potential, but the quality just didn't hold up.

I have this liner in 3 shades. It goes on nicely and smoothly, and dries quickly. I have thin lips and like to line just a tad over the line (no "Lucy Lips" here). It matches well with the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tints I bought them to go with. The reason for only 3 stars because after about 2-3 hours, it will start to crack. I am SO disappointed, as they match perfectly. I got them for 5.99, so I'm on the fence as to whether I will bother to send them back. As for the colors, I got the Cherry Red, but it is a deep burgundy. Almost brown. I was hoping for a nice red. The Orchid is pretty true to an orchid color (a pinky/lavender). The Deep Red is a wine-ish shade. I am disappointed in the quality, and will not re-purchase, but I guess at the price point, I was expecting more.

I am giving these 5 stars because they were exactly as described. I however did not like them and it was my fault for not reading that they are tattoo liners and not the peelable kind. They stay really well though and they are bold! They are kind of dry once they dry if that makes sense. But they do stay on well.

Nice color, just a tad darker than I used to. Applies smoothly. Long lasting. Just be careful to make sure lid is on tight after using. My fault applicator dried out, but actually was more my shade afterwards and easily outlined and spread on lips more to my liking!

Shade is not good dries out lips. I would not recommend this product.

Bought a 3 pack that included this color. Others were more red & salmon colors. Now I know what number color I like to order separately! Doesn’t dry lips & isn’t sticky. Color lasts once it dries, which is quickly. Unless I use lip gloss, color doesn’t smudge off on anything.

I like the product overall but when I wiped it off my lips my lips were straight up GREEN. The lid was leaking a green fluid when I opened it on one of the two I got and I’m sure that isn’t what it is supposed to be doing. It’s probably a defective product but I do like the product as it is. It’s light and doesn’t smudge and looks nice and doesn’t feather out of the lip line at all. It is a nice stain and is thicker than most stains so it is easy to apply and use. I definitely wouldn’t use it if I had to go somewhere bare faced the next day because of the green color it left 😂 but I overall do like the look and feel and I’ll be ordering a couple more shades to try out!