BeautyGARDE Oil-Free Liquid Eyeliner - safe for lash extensions, precision silicone applicator, Nonie Creme

Smudge proof, stays on all day (12 + hours) worth the investment

A little tricky to get on but most important is that it lasted and was not irritating to my very sensitive eyes. Washed off easy too!

I was very pleasantly surprised by this eyeliner. I do think it’s helped my eyelash extensions stay on a little longer (in addition to the eyelash extension friendly makeup remover I use). I’m not the biggest fan of the super thin brush because you have to keep dipping it back in to get more product, but the eyeliner liquid itself is pretty good. If anyone’s wondering about the amount of product — I’ve been using it everyday since late March and it seems like it probably has enough liquid for a couple more weeks.

If you are not good with liquid eyeliner application, this is going to be very hard. The color is very dark and bold. It is easy to tell if you mess up your line. And it is not the easiest to remove. You will need lots of makeup remover. I gave it 3 stars because I had a lot of problems applying it, but I am not a big makeup person and struggled with my lines.

Just what I was looking for. I have lash extensions and love this product. It’s easy to clean off won’t get stuck in lashes and is very matte black!

I’m super disappointed by this product. I have lash extensions so I was looking for an oil-free, lash safe eyeliner & this is NOT it. It made my lashes all sticky & when trying to brush them out, my lashes fell out! DO NOT USE IF YOU HAVE LASH EXTENSIONS!!!

Super delicate for eyelash extensions. It was recommended to me by my lash artist. The mascara is not your typical glob-on super black mascara. But it does accentuate your lashes more.

This is perfect for my lash extensions. Very vivid and dark!