TONYMOLY Panda's Dream

Literally no smudging. Which is a miracle! When it gets wet in warm water, it just kind of comes off in black strands. So, don’t cry.

Relatively cheap (was using YSL Effets Faux Cils), DOES NOT SMUDGE, separates and lengthens (I use the lengthening formula) my short Asian lashes, holds curl from a lash curler without need of a primer, and rinses off easily with warm water. I use the applicator w the curve out 1st then use the curve to emphasize the outer lashes and lift. AMAZING!Don’t let the panda fool you - this mascara is my HG!

I have used this product for about two years and will not buy any other mascara ever again. It is rain, tears, and sweat proof. Comes out SUPER easily when you simply massage your lashes with your fingers and a little water, which sounds weird but is faster and incredibly convenient for when you don't have makeup remover. Unlike with other mascaras and make-up wipes I have not lost eyelashes to trying to get it out and never gotten racoon/black under eyes when trying to get it off. Family and friends who I have recommended it to have also loved it and buy it regularly now.

The first order I received was amazing, and I left a five-star review. I was so excited to order another. However, the next two I bought were HORRIBLE. One was so dried out and old that I had to request a refund. I thought I would try again thinking it was just a fluke, so I bought a third tube. This tube is a total nightmare- I have never experienced anything like it. Huge clumps come exploding out of the tube when I try to use it and clump so badly that I can't use it without getting gooey caterpillar lashes. It's a total mess, going in the trash and I am done with this mascara. Sucks.

Definitely works! It made my lashes look a lot longer and defined. I worked out with it on and it didn’t smudge, but came off easily in the shower.

I wanted to find a cheaper alternative to my usual DHC tubing mascara. This Tonymoly panda dream mascara is always recommended side by side with DHC so I thought I would give it a try. To me, it's not a close comparison at all. The mascara applied clumpy and the formula was very dry. I will never buy this again and do not recommend it.

This is hands down the best mascara i have ever owned.It really doesn't smudge, and it stays on super clean.I slept in it last night, face mashed into my flannel pillow, and only had a couple flakes. I considered throwing on a little more and going to work but the rest of my face needed a rinse. Comes off super clean without a lot of work, I just use water + cedaphil daily.I've been wearing it for about a month now and I am no less impressed.

So cute!!! I absolutely love this. I was also pleased when I saw that it's not too thick. It's perfect.