Better Than Gnawin Forever Toy and Chew

My dog and my son's dog both love these chew treats. They claim that they can last up to 2 hours, but my 70 pound lab mix can usually finish it off in about an hour, so they don't last as long as I'd hoped or I would have given them 5 stars. Unfortunately, I can only find them now online, so I usually buy several of the refills at a time. So far my dog has not broken the outer holder, so they are pretty sturdy. There are other similar type chew toys out there, but my dog still likes these the best.

I have a black lab who is a vigorous chewer. This looked like it would be a great idea. Although the concept seemed good, she was able to have it apart and chewed up the ends in 10 minutes. Probably not good for vigorous chewers or "smart" dogs that can figure out how things come apart.

My dog loves these Gnawin Forever chew toys. Walmart use to carry them but they were discontinued. The refills sometimes do not fit and they are at times not in stock. He spends hour chewing on this item.

Sorry, but had to say that, my dog loved this, I had to take it from her or she would have made herself sick on it. It also kept her busy for a long time.

I was very leery of dropping $20 on a dog toy, but figured that if it did what it said, it would be worth the price + the refills. We gave it to our dog(85 lb American Bulldog mix) yesterday. She was disinterested for the first 5 minutes (it doesn't seem to smell that good), but eventually figured out that it was edible.I came back not 10 minutes later and she had popped the side off the toy and was just chewing on the center. We managed to put it back together and gave it back to her. The next time I looked at it the center was nowhere to be seen, I assume she just chewed it off.Fun in concept, but not good for strong chewers.

This is a wonderful invention and our dog loves it. Unfortunately he loves it a little too much and will wear himself slap out licking and licking - and to our dismay, he was sneaking right under our noses and eating the red plastic around it to get better traction on the treat. That was unexpected because it appears to be pretty hard plastic. Just keep an eye on your pup until you know what he'll do - I wouldn't recommend leaving your dog alone with this, especially if he figures out how to eat the plastic - it can't be good for him.

Advertised to keep pet busy for hours because they would used their front teeth on this product. My dog figured out in under 5 minutes how to remove the treat. I was so disappointed.

The dog loves this toy! She hasn't chewed through the first one yet, the title speaks for it's self