4 Pcs Matte Lip Liner Pencil Sets,Retractable Waterproof Lip Liner Pencil,High Pigmented Lipliner for Daily Makeup,Lipstick Long Lasting Smudge Proof for Women,No Sharpener Required

Wasn’t sure about this purchase?? The colors are so pretty, very creamy, not dry at all. Easy application. Very happy with this purchase. The price was on point. Long lasting.

The color is fine but the smell is very chemical. Also they are very drying. The color last is average. Will not repurchase.

I have worn this brand for over 10 years and just love it. When I saw this color, I thought it was a very pretty neutral shade. But when I got it, it was way darker than it looked online. It’s more of a burgundy color or like a wine. Not the pale mauve that I was looking for. Really disappointed.

They work and last pretty well . The colors are the same as the picture. The texture is nice throughout the day. They work as a liner or lipstick.

I heard about these on TokTok from Nina Pool. These are very pigmented. They go on smooth too. The only reason why I didn’t give a 5 star rating is because they bleed if you like the 3-D lip look and I am not a fan of the smell.

The colors look like a wine (great), a dark red, an orange and i'm not sure what the brown is supposed to be, but it's not brown. So where does the nude come in? It does go on smooth and 1/2 of them I can wear and are a nice color, but the other ones doesn't look like the color in the picture shown. Too orange for me, but you may like them.

Great colors! Smooth & easy application. Lasts for hours.

Pencil set seemed "dried out" when applying. Had decent pigment once applied, but was not as smooth of a process as I thought it would be. Expected that since it was a twist up liner, it would have gone on a bit more smoothly.