The Geometry of Physics: An Introduction
P**Z
Third Edition Best of Class & Only Modern Text in this Genre
Some texts are designed to increase understanding, others to aid in practical computation, making them as much references as pedagogic tools. The latter are especially suited for self study. In this new edition, Frankel does something amazing-- instead of completely reorganizing an already stellar text, he "ties it all together" with a new "example" introduction-- a 34 page (roman numeral numbered!) "preface" illustrating Cartan's exterior differential forms with a "metal torsion" example application to Cauchy's stress tensor.Don't mistakely think that this means Frankel limits this text to the differential geometry of engineering mechanics and materials-- he covers a vast field of physics all the way from classic to quantum, sans string but with numerous gauge applications, in 750 packed pages, most containing fully worked out calculations for the aforementioned reference value.It seems today that all publishers just parrot "for grad students or advanced undergrads with a year of calculus and some linear algebra." Is this to sell more books? Not sure, but I wouldn't tackle this for self study or even calculative reference without "advanced" calculus (in my definition, analysis) PLUS a good course in analytic geometry first. Although this is packed with AG, it does not start by teaching AG-- the geometry knowledge is assumed, and we're then treated to an astonishing adventure of detailed APPLICATIONS of geometry to nearly every aspect of physics, including numerous cutting edge and intractable problems. There also are NUMEROUS engineering applications examples, blending physics, engineering and geometry in a way no other text even attempts.I've long felt that some pundits who tease the Greeks for seeing everything as geometric would someday eat their words. Well.. wow. This volume clearly demonstrates how much what comes round goes round. OK, looking at physical spheres is not the same as spacetime curvature spheres, let alone "field" geometry that isn't even a physical geometry, but the geometry of a vector bundle!So, to be honest, if you see the word "introduction" in this text's title, and think you'll be guided through the UNDERSTANDING of Lie algebras, matrix calculus, Yang-Mills and other gauges via geometry-- be careful. "Introduction" as I read it after reading this text means intro to the APPLICATION and CALCULATION techniques available to someone already well grounded in analytic geometry. Don't get me wrong, the author is simply amazing, as were the very successful first two editions, in carefully explaining many neglected applications of AG to physics, but this book would be 3,000 pages if we actually expected it to "introduce" every notation. So, it does blast right off assuming a good base in analytic geometry, and a fair base in physics.One really cool dimension for self-study-- the author is obviously first a mathematician, and within that a geometer, so the pedagogic artifact from older days of showing NUMEROUS diagrams and illustrations made its way into this fine text. Even if I weigh the overall presentation as more computational that didactic, the illustrations themselves bely that evaluation-- each one gives one of those "aha" moments. The author also does take the time to explain the WHY of certain formula elements so you really "get" them. For example, if we're given an element where x^(exp polynomial) = b*(expression), the author WILL digress enough to remind us that b is acting as a proportionality constant. I find this really helpful as a way to generalize the lesson learned, otherwise we're just rote memorizing or referring back to a process we're not really getting! Highly recommended with the caveats mentioned about brushing up on your analytic/ differential geometry.Library Picks reviews only for the benefit of Amazon shoppers and has nothing to do with Amazon, the authors, manufacturers or publishers of the items we review. We always buy the items we review for the sake of objectivity, and although we search for gems, are not shy about trashing an item if it's a waste of time or money for Amazon shoppers. If the reviewer identifies herself, her job or her field, it is only as a point of reference to help you gauge the background and any biases.
D**P
Highly recommended. Wish Kindle ebook was PDF instead of EPUB
Highly recommended. It's well written, covers a lot of material, and is suitable for self study . I wish that the Kindle ebook were a PDF ebook for which the equations are always properly sized in proportion to the text (available from ebooks and vitalsource at much greater cost). I also recommend the classic Differential Forms by Harley Flanders. It's much shorter but still covers some important material such as the converse to the Poincare Lemma, the Frobenius theorem, and an elegant concise derivation of the Riemann tensor-valued curvature two-forms, the Bianchi identity, and the Einstein tensor. But much that is discussed in Frankel's book is entirely missing from Flander's book, such as Frankel's elegant treatment of the Lie derivative, even though it is somewhat sloppy in its treatment of time-dependent "flows" on a manifold M, which can be made onto true flows by considering an extended manifold RxM. Usually when he says that the Lie derivative with respect to the flow vector field X on RxM of a particular time-dependent differential form with no dt^ terms is zero, what he really means is that it's zero after discarding any dt^ terms.
G**E
Topics are great. Notation and typesetting could be improved
Topics are great. Notation and typesetting could be improved, but since this is already the 3rd edition, I can only say I don't understand the author/publisher's decision of insisting on using unconventional notations every now and then and such ugly typesetting.
G**N
Highly Recommend
Excellent for both physicists and mathematicians. Essentially a differential geometry textbook and how physics has motivated its development and is inherently connected to it. Starts with the basics of manifolds and continues into highly advanced, specialized topics with numerous applications to physics throughout. Writing is not too terse, but not so clear as to where the author is doing the thinking for you. Numerous exercises sprinkle the text, usually at the end of each section. Some sections are full problem sets, with a few definitions and remarks as you develop and apply the tools (such as hamiltonians) through problems. Packed with information that will keep you occupied for months. Pre-requisites include a firm grasp in both mechanics, electromagnetism, and special relativity, as well as an excellent understanding of linear algebra and multi-dimensional analysis. Dr. Shifrin's youtube videos would be a good start or review for the math pre-reqs.In regards to delivery and quality of book -- on time and superb, respectively.
A**S
Such a great work!
I'm happy with the book. It offers an insightful perspective that I learned to really appreciate. My understanding about physics was greatly enhanced by the combined knowledge of Frankel book and the book "Geometrical methods of mathematical physics" by Schultz. I am really impressed by how much intuition one can gain by developing a geometrical view of modern physics. In fact, I can't emphasize enough how important such knowledge is for a professional physicist.
C**C
The negative review is about the printing not the book
Newly printed paperback books from Cambridge University Press seem to be printed on demand with low quality ink and papers are no longer the glossy and shiny ones. Very disappointed!
N**N
Great book!
The Geometry of Physics is written in a very modern style and with a great choice of topics. A mathematician can enjoy this book even though it is mathematical physics. The mathematics is presented in very nice form.
A**O
A Well Written Book.
Frankel is an excellent teacher, and did a great job with this book.
Trustpilot
Hace 1 mes
Hace 1 semana