BEHR Premium1-Gal. Cedar Naturaltone Weatherproofing Solid Color Wood Stain

It appears I have the exact same issue as Cheryl's review. The deck and fence was stained with a Behr Cedar tone, which is more red..used 18+ years. And the Cedar naturaltone, used on the deck gate is not the same color at all. Did they change the name to redwood or something?

My deck's stain is peeling and even after sanding it, I could not get it all off, so I decided to use the solid color of the Cedar Naturaltone. Well if I use this, it will not cover it up because it's not even close in color.I called Behr and she told it was supposed to be that yellowish color, well then which color is wrong, because they are named the same.I"m showing a paint stick with the solid color 50533, laying on top of the deck stained with the semi-transparent 501- Cedar Naturaltone. The 50533 is a very ugly color to paint a deck in my opinion.