CLIO Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Eye Liner | Micro Precision Tip (2mm), Twist Up, Self-Sharpening, Long Lasting, Smudge-Resistant, High-Intensity Color, Ultra-Smooth | Maroon Brown (#04)

The media could not be loaded.  I have hooded eyelids and this is great for tight lining. Very smooth and glides on so easily.I would only recommend this for tight lining underneath the top lashes. It smudges very easily if used as eyeliner on the upper and lower lid.

Older women do not look good in black and dark brown eye liners! I've been looking for a light brown ever since the one pencil I was able to locate a year ago started making my eyelids itch last month, so I bought 6 different eye pencils last week in varying shades of brown, and this one is perfect! I bought Cacao Brown. It is matte, not sparkly, it goes on easily and stays on until I remove it, and the color looks natural with my light honey colored hair. I wear it on my upper and lower lids, not the water line, so I can't speak to that. So glad I got this one! The other 5 I bought were useless!

This eyeliner did not disappoint at all. I smudge it out before it dries and it stays put with no transfer all day. I have very oily eyelids everything creases or transfers so I am extremely happy to have found this. Most of the browns have red in them. I found the dark brown to be the most neutral in tone and it’s also the color I was looking for

I have mono lids and I absolutely love using the dark brown color to line my waterline, it doesn't smudge at all and it stays all day! The only caveat is that it doesn't have much in it and it always feels like I'm using a lot at once so I feel like I'm going through each pencil very quickly. Aside from that, highly recommend!

This stuff is awesome. I am in my 50's skins getting thin and papery and every time I used "waterproof" eyeliner I look like a old sick racoon. I wore this to bed and still woke looking ok. I wish I had this in my 20's.

Ok so I barely write reviews and this one deserves it. They change the formula on the eyeliner I was using which was cover girl point ink it, they made it thicker and makes my eyes smudging I hate it I hate the new formula because it’s not pointy anymore. So I’ve been buying different type of eyeliners and they always break off, or they’re thick just like the one I don’t like it make my eyes smudgy, So I finally found exactly what I like it gel type where smooth when you draw it on but it doesn’t smudge and it stays on for a long time it’s waterproof. I love it so much that I bought another one in brown and maroon brown. I just wish I was a little bit cheaper

This is the holy grail liner for me. I am East Asian and have double eyelids, so most eye makeup transfers and fades after a time. Not so with this liner. It stays put and is very very black. Be careful when you close the cap, it can come off and it will dry out. You can fix it by rubbing it on a tissue until the dried part breaks off, but you do waste some product that way.

I have tried many types of eyeliner - pen, pencil, brush etc. Nothing seemed to go on EASY! Pencil you have to sharpen, pens are very harsh and brushes are hard to apply. This eyeliner goes on my eye very SMOOTHLY! Doesn't pull on my eyelid! I bought the cocoa and I really like it. Maybe not the best staying power on the bottom lid (I do have problems with tearing occasionally) but it's the best eyeliner I've found in a LONG time!

Goes on nicely. Doesn't smudge. Comes off easy enough. There's a sparkle to it, but only you will be able to see it.Never needs sharpening so that's great and I get the line size I want on my eyes.